Resources Mentioned in this Episode
Please note that this transcript was auto-generated. We apologize for any minor errors in spelling or grammar.
Jonathan Hughes: [00:00:00] Every year, colleges have this enormous task, distribute their financial aid dollars to students as fairly as possible. Now, just for a minute, think about what they set out to do. Review every student’s family’s financial picture and assess how much of the price of college they should be able to shoulder.
That means looking at income, savings, property taxes, household size, businesses, farms. It means comparing families with two parents, single-parent families, independent students, and students in legal guardianship. And it means comparing families that live in California, Massachusetts, West Virginia, Mississippi, and Hawaii.
It’s extraordinarily complex, and at the same time, we want families, as many families as necessary, to get financial aid So there’s basically two ways you can go about making this happen. One [00:01:00] is to make the process and the questions as general as possible. Don’t get too bogged down in the details.
Provide a low hurdle that most families can clear easily. That’s the way most colleges have chosen to go in that they only require the FAFSA to apply for financial aid. Simplicity is prized in the FAFSA process, and the FAFSA information is good enough for most colleges, but not for all. Some colleges that give out a lot of their own institutional money as aid to students and have many worthy applicants, need more information than what a simplified FAFSA can give them.
It’s these colleges that may ask you to file an additional financial aid form called the CSS Profile, and thus students applying to those colleges should file both a FAFSA and a CSS Profile if they want aid from that college. And here to talk about the philosophy of the CSS Profile, how the colleges that [00:02:00] use it assess need versus those that just use the FAFSA, and how families can actually file the application, is our friend Jim Slattery, the Dean of Student Financial Services at a school that requires the CSS Profile, Northeastern University.
Jim, welcome back to the MEFA podcast.
Jim Slattery: Thank you. Happy to be here.
Jonathan Hughes: You are at Northeastern, which is a school that requires the CSS Profile. Correct.
Jim Slattery: Yep.
Jonathan Hughes: And so I guess my first question, I want to talk about the how, but first I want to talk about the why- Yeah … of the CSS profile. I know the FAFSA is foremost in a lot of people’s minds- Yeah
and they view the CSS Profile as a secondary form. And why would you have to file a CSS Profile if you’ve already filed a FAFSA? So can you speak to that?
Jim Slattery: If you don’t mind, let me start with the FAFSA, because the FAFSA, as you just alluded to, is the form used by every institution that administers financial aid.
As a frame of reference, we’re talking over four thousand institutions [00:03:00] nationally, right? The FAFSA has changed over the years. It’s been simplified. There are fewer questions, there are fewer data points, all positive things, right? Much of that has to do with access. It has to do with simplicity for families.
But what it means now is the FAFSA has become an eligibility determinant for federal funds. It’s less now as a measure of economic circumstances in a family’s ability to pay. That means then if you’re a private institution and you have significant dollars, and in some cases we’re talking institutions that award tens in some cases hundreds of millions of dollars annually in their own money, then they want more information and more significant information than what the FAFSA provides, right?
So if you start with that as a starting point, then you have an alternative. You could say, “I’ll ask for an additional form over and above the FAFSA. I could create my own application.” The implications for [00:04:00] families, first-time families then is you might have to complete a FAFSA and then complete six other institutional apps for six private institutions.
College Board, they’re the SAT people as we know, the AP people, but they also work within the financial aid world. Private institutions, not exclusively, but primarily private institutions, have worked with the College Board over the years to create an alternative to the FAFSA. And so most institutions that use the profile, they’re saying, “We don’t get enough information from FAFSA.
We need more But we don’t want to intrude on families either and have them do 10 different applications. So instead, we’ll use this other Common Application and hope that if they might be applying to other private institutions, then they can do a second application and know that it, that information can go to multiple schools.
Jonathan Hughes: What can families and students expect to be different about- Sure … the profile?
Jim Slattery: It’s a good question, a good perspective. Primary differences are the FAFSA, the profile, excuse me, has a [00:05:00] deeper look at assets. So the most common that’s talked about is home equity. The FAFSA many years ago asked information about family home equity, value of the home, and the debt of the home.
That’s been eliminated for many years. The profile still asks for that information. The FAFSA very recently stopped using siblings in college, so it used to look at whether the applicant had other family members in college, and that made a significant difference in eligibility. The profile still looks at family members in college, number in college, and the family.
The pro- the FAFSA, excuse me, does not. The profile will ask for some information, but not all s- colleges use it. The profile has the ability to ask for deeper information regarding self-employment or businesses.
The profile will ask for information about retirement assets, although I don’t know any institutions that use that information.
It’s data, but it’s not necessarily in the formula and methodology. But the big ones are number in college, the home [00:06:00] equity piece, other types of assets. Those are the big differences.
Jonathan Hughes: I was going to ask about noncustodial parents, but we can, but we can-
Jim Slattery: That’s okay. I was just going to mention that. Okay, yeah.
The other primary difference I should have talked about that is the FAFSA will look at information primarily from what they call the custodial parent. They have very specific definitions for that, and the methodology and the formula explores only that custodial parent’s information with the student information.
The profile asks for information from generally what we would call the biological family, so the, what’s presumed to be the custodial parent from the FAFSA, although profile no longer calls that custodial parent, but say the primary family for the student, and then it still looks at or asks for at least on the surface information from the other biological parent and respective spouses and so on. So it asks for a lot of information.
Jonathan Hughes: Thanks, Jim. By the way, if you know someone who’s struggling with completing a CSS profile or the prospect of [00:07:00] completing a CSS profile, go ahead and send them this episode. It may help. Since we’re on the topic of noncustodial parents- Yeah … I was going to talk about this a little bit later, but I’ll ask now.
Yeah. Because this always drives calls, and I’m sure you know where I’m going with this. Yeah. What if there is a situation where the noncustodial parent it’s going to be an issue?
Jim Slattery: Colleges have sympathy for this, right? So we recognize sometimes these can be complicated kinds of things. I’ll also throw in an old adage in the aid community that all of these calculations, and this was the case even originally with FAFSA, that the best the calculations can do is measure something like ability to pay, which helps determine eligibility for aid. It can’t measure willingness to pay.
Jonathan Hughes: Yep.
Jim Slattery: We can’t measure willingness to pay, which means we don’t consider willingness to pay. And for, for a kid, that could be a tough thing, right? We understand that. But it’s really the only way to ensure some fairness in the process, to [00:08:00] say we’re not measuring willingness to pay.
When we go from there, then it becomes information that the student might need to share with the institution as to what kinds of contact they have with the other parent how long they haven’t had contact. Some of that bec- is ve- very pain- painful. It’s always personal, but institutions will take that into consideration.
It sounds like I just danced around your question, so let me give you a couple of examples. We have families sometimes who apply. They say “My non-custodial parent won’t participate, and I have no contact with the non-custodial parent.” There’s a process for applying for a waiver then from submitting the noncustodial parent information. From a financial perspective, there’s contact. So from a financial perspective, most institutions are gonna say, “We want that information.” In other cases, there’s no information, and the student can demonstrate, “I haven’t had contact with that [00:09:00] noncustodial parent in 20 years. There’s no measure of financial support.
The person’s MIA.” We have ways to demonstrate that and to identify that, and in those cases, we’re gonna waive the requirement for the other information. The more complicated ones are the ones that are in between, right? And most institutions will work personally with the families, but for those in between ones, there’s no straight answer.
The initial expectation is that you get information from both parents, and then institutions will try to be very fair with that information.
Jonathan Hughes: One of the questions that I get asked from time to time, and not in an explicit way, but when I’m talking with families about assets you mentioned assets, so savings, property, any kind of assets that, that may be looked at in terms of measuring a family’s ability to pay.
I know how the FAFSA treats assets of the parent because, we do savings programs. We like to talk about how important it is to save and how saving only [00:10:00] minimally impacts your financial aid, and I’m able to say in the federal methodology, you’re only going to be assessed at most 5.6% of a parent’s total assets as to what you can pay for college.
If you’ve got $10,000 in assets, that’s gonna increase your expected contribution, as they used to call it, by at most $560. I know with the profile it’s a little bit different but I don’t know if you can speak to how the profile views assets or if it’s as simple as a percentage or if that’s something that different colleges can take into account differently.
Jim Slattery: As a starting point, it treats it philosophically the same.
Jonathan Hughes: Okay.
Jim Slattery: In other words the, the presumption is the expectation from assets should be a far lower percentage than, say, an expectation from income, right? Income, more liquid, more current assets, especially something like home equity, Deeper, less liquid and so on. The philosophy’s the same. Even the math is similar. While you [00:11:00] quoted the worst case 5.6%- … there’s a worst case on the Profile side it’s in the same range. Okay. But it’s a truly a worst case. Number one, in many cases, depending on the calculation, the, the percentage is much less. Very often it’s 0% depending on other calculations.
Jonathan Hughes: Income and whatnot, if your income level is low-
Jim Slattery: Exactly … okay … income level and in the case of Profile, family size and other kinds of- Okay … attributes, right? But the philosophy’s the same. The bigger difference I would say with Profile is less the philosophy of the calculation, but what’s included, right?
So by nature, FAFSA, we’re looking at cash, savings, banking accounts, current assets, not home equity, which is a big one for families. For Profile, they’re looking at that home equity, which can be a significant number for families, but the, the philosophy’s the same, that it’s still a small percentage from assets.
It’s something I remind families ’cause when they’re asked about home equity’s a personal thing, right? It becomes very personal. For some families, it’s the [00:12:00] only means of generational wealth for that particular family. And so no one wants to be worried about their home equity or giving up home equity in order to pay for college.
But the reminder is, again, that small percentage, as you referenced, it’s typically no higher than the 5, 6% range, and that’s a worst case, and very often it’s lower. So philosophy’s the same for Profile. The difference is more types of assets would be included than compared to the FAFSA.
Jonathan Hughes: One other savings question I have that, that I get asked from time to time, I actually just met with a family that asked this question, and that is 529s, for example, or assets that are owned by somebody other than the parent. Now on the FAFSA, they don’t get viewed as an asset, right? How is that viewed on the Profile?
Jim Slattery: The whole nature of Profile is there’s a default kind of formula and a standardized formula out of the gate, but institutions have the prerogative to change that formula a little bit or to include or exclude elements of the formula.[00:13:00]
So I can’t guarantee that an institution might ask a family, “I want to know about 529 plans from the grandparents,” but the default formula does not include it. It does not ask for that information. Most schools that I know of never ask for that information. However, if part of that 529 plan is used as a distribution or for support in a particular year, then that needs to be reported, and that’s reported as a resource for the student, just like any other outside resource, a third-party scholarship, or other support from families and so on. So that should be reported, but the asset itself does not need to be reported.
Jonathan Hughes: A big question that I have, and at least it’s a perception I think out there is that since the profile asks for more information, they, they may ask for the value of your primary home, it’ll ask for your retirement, you’re going to get less aid a- at a Profile school. Can you speak to what the reality is?
Jim Slattery: If we look at the formula itself, we looked at the raw formula, [00:14:00] there was a day where because the profile asked for more information, more detailed information, more… let’s just say more assets, right? Use that home equity as an example. Statistically, if you looked across a s- a data set Profile contributions might be higher than the FAFSA contributions.
To some extent, that’s still the case. However, I’ll add a few data points ’cause to answer your question. A number of years ago, profile users and the College Board changed the formula- … so that statistically they have more generous allowances within the formula. So while they might ask for more assets, there are generally more generous allowances.
More recently, they’re still including siblings in college, which can be a main factor in this formula and calculation that the FAFSA no longer has. So even a number of years ago, we could see statistically, nationally, and I see it at my school, anywhere from 25 to 40% of the contributions through profile would be actually [00:15:00] lower than FAFSA, so eligibility would be higher.
With the changes to the sibling piece on FAFSA, we see even higher percentages now. So the truth is, across the board, do you see higher contributions often with profile? Yes. Do we see it less commonly than we did a number of years ago? That’s also true. And then the last thing I would say is this: the profile users again, for perspective, we talked about thousands of FAFSA users. Profile users, the, the set of profile users is several hundred There aren’t a ton of institutions. They’re primarily privates, but not exclusively.
They’re primarily more expensive privates. They’re also the better resourced institutions. They also have the most generous aid policies. They have significant dollars that they can apply toward aid.
So when you look at the numbers, looking at net cost for families, so while you might see higher contributions from profile, when you look at net costs, [00:16:00] very often lower for those more expensive institutions ’cause they also have more dollars to contribute. And because they’re more confident about their calculation, they can feel comfortable contributing higher dollars.
Jonathan Hughes: This is interesting. So we’re drawing a distinction then between the need that the formula demonstrates that you have versus the dollars that you actually get from the colleges. Is that correct?
Jim Slattery: Yeah, it’s an important distinction.
Jonathan Hughes: It is, yeah.
Jim Slattery: So on paper, we can look at a family and say, “This family is eligible for $50,000 in aid.”
And we can have an institution that says, “We know it’s 50,000. We feel comfortable with the number, but based on our resources, we can only give that family 30.” At that point, the calculation isn’t that meaningful for that particular family, right? Sure. If you can only get 30 out of the 50. But as I said, strongly resourced institutions, and again they’re often the more expensive ones, they will very often f- feel just fine saying, “You’re eligible for 50, you get [00:17:00] $50,000.”
That’s a great point. “You’re eligible for 90, you get $90,000.” So it’s a significant point, and it’s something families should always know when they’re applying. They look at high price institutions as, I’m afraid.” Very often those high price institutions may end up being your lowest expense institutions comparatively because of the resources that they have, right?
Jonathan Hughes: I wanna switch now to talk About the how you file the profile instead of the why. So for the FAFSA, there is a preferred sort of flow of events for filing. Essentially, the student goes and gets their FSA ID all parties do, but the student starts their FAFSA, especially with the new simplified flow, completes their section of the FAFSA, emails a link to the parent then completes their section of the FAFSA, and then they submit. Is there a preferred order of operations when it comes to [00:18:00] filing the profile, or how is that done?
Jim Slattery: I don’t know if it’s a preferred order. Again, conceptually, the p- the profile is done very similarly, right? Student is the primary applicant, which is a good side point for families. This is someone who works often with the F- FAFSA that a common mistake is the parent who’s helping complete the form, and they begin to answer questions that are student questions as their own- information. They’re providing their own information for student information. So that’s an important distinction. So for both processes, the student is the primary applicant. So f- profile, just like FAFSA, it makes sense for the student to start the application. The student very often is already in the College Board ecosystem because they might have had score reports or other kinds of things.
Jonathan Hughes: Because the College Board also manages the SAT.
Jim Slattery: Correct. And they may not. They may be taking the SAT. It’s fi… the ACT. Excuse me. It’s fine. But it’s easy enough to create an account. They become the primary applicant, and the form will, rather than the FSA ID [00:19:00] style thing, it’s similar in that the, the parent can create an access point for profile.
If the parent and the student are together during that initial sitting, they can begin to provide information for parent information and so on. So where there becomes a little divergence or distinction is we noted earlier that the FAFSA includes information only about the custodial parent, right? So profile, the primary information is gonna be the equivalent.
And I like to tell families, “If you’ve determined the custodial parent on the FAFSA, that should be the parent that’s aligned with the student on the profile application.” Yep. Again, even though profile won’t call it custodial parent, that’s your primary parent and primary parent information. The profile will then ask information about the other biological parent, and then at some point after the student submits the information, there will be instructions in order for the second parent, the biological parent, to go into the profile [00:20:00] service, complete information.
They do it separately from the custodial parent, and that’s significant for privacy reasons. Sometimes those splits were not amic- amicable necessarily- Sure … and so neither party wants the other to see that information. The College Board and colleges recognize that, and we want to honor that and sympathize with that.
So there’s a distinct information stream for that non-custodial, that secondary parent, but it’s a very direct common sense thing. Bottom line is the, the, the, the principle’s the same. Student is primary applicant. Custodial parent sh- putting in information without an FSA ID necessarily. But they’re linked to name and an email address.
Non-custodial or the other biological parent can do the same using an email link and using an email address and information that the student has designated on the initial application.
Jonathan Hughes: I want to break in one more time to let you know that MEFA has all sorts of tools and resources available to help you with your [00:21:00] CSS Profile, including the recorded webinars, What to Know About the CSS Profile, and Ask an Expert all of your CSS Profile questions.
You can find these in our resource center on mefa.org, and at mefa.org you can also request a one-on-one appointment with a MEFA counselor to help you with your financial aid questions. Or you can also email us any questions you may have at [email protected]. Now back to the show. I have a question about supporting documents because, unlike the FAFSA, the profile often requires supporting documents to be submitted, and that, part of the reason you mentioned FAFSA simplification earlier, part of the thing that makes it so simple is that you can use the data exchange from the IRS to take tax and income information in and directly populate it into the FAFSA, so you don’t need to get your taxes out and submit them and things like that.
Yeah. It’s not the same with the profile, right? So how… What might be [00:22:00] asked of families filing the profile, and how are those submitted?
Jim Slattery: You’ve alluded to some of it. Tax returns W-2 forms underlying those tax returns 1099s if they exist, and W-2s if they exist. Those are common asks. In some cases, as I mentioned, if the, if one of the parents is a business owner, there might be other tax forms related to the business that an institution might ask for.
Those are the most common kinds of asks. There might be associated documents with some of those things. So for example, for the student in high school who doesn’t work, you can’t extract a tax form from a kid if they never filed taxes. So there might be a form where they say, “I don’t work,” or, “I did work but didn’t file taxes.”
That’s okay. There’s a process for that and a form for that. Some of the application differences might come into play is some institutions ask for that information up front, some ask for it as a follow-up. Most who ask for it up front, they’re very upfront. Sorry for the pun. They’re very upfront about [00:23:00] that.
It’s very openly declared on their website. It’s declared in the… If they’re participating in the profile process, it’s declared with, on information from the college board. When a, a student looks at Northeastern’s information, they can see Northeastern asks for this information, they don’t ask for this.
There’s a thing called a business farm supplement that some institutions ask for self-employed families. We don’t ask for that upfront. Other institutions may. That will be displayed on the college board site And then you ask a very good follow-up to that then, what are the means of sending that information?
That can vary as well. College Board provides a service called IDOC, the Institutional Documentation service. They allow families to upload tax returns to a very safe and secure portal. Again, with the intent that if families are applying to multiple institutions that require those tax documents, they can upload once, and the institutions individually can access that information with their profile [00:24:00] information.
We do that. Other institutions may want you to send the documents directly. They’ll provide that information. They typically have secure portals, a secure means to do that. It could vary from institution to institution, so families should check. But there are some common ways to do that, and IDOC tied in with the profile process is one of them.
And again, not all institutions ask for those upfront, but many do.
Jonathan Hughes: I want to talk about deadlines too.
Jim Slattery: Yeah.
Jonathan Hughes: Because I know as we often talk about deadlines are really important in the financial aid process. There’s some processing time though, right? So when you hit submit on the profile, is that as of when, have you met your deadline then or do you need to allow a few days for things to process and be sent to the college?
And then where does that, IDOC submission thing come in? What’s, what is the true deadline for the profile? And does that… I’m imagining that may vary from college to college, does it?
Jim Slattery: Yes.
Jonathan Hughes: Okay.
Jim Slattery: Yes. So the, the [00:25:00] answer to your question is what’s the true deadline? There’s no truth to this- Okay
’cause it could vary from college to college, honestly.
Jonathan Hughes: Okay.
Jim Slattery: I can tell you most colleges look, e- even if some of their information online, their declared information might not have certainty. If they s- if they have a deadline and it doesn’t say in-house or submission, more institutions try to be sympathetic w- to the family view of that, so it might say submitted by. They might have distinct language.
Most that don’t have that kind of distinct language look at submission dates. We look at submission dates. We’re not gonna look for an in-house date, and especially some of that’s within our control. So even if you submitted on time and you, and it was processed on time, if for whatever strange reason we don’t bring it into our system within that window of time, we’re not gonna penalize families for that.
And that’s how most institutions work. But the… as a general rule, it should be, and it’s applicable for deadlines. Check what the institution’s [00:26:00] requirements are, right? That’s a… That should be the general rule. They can vary, so there’s no truth to this. But most institutions look at Submission dates, they get all of these processes have electronic tracking and electronic information that’s shared.
So the FAFSA- … can tell you the date that the form was submitted, the date it was processed, the date it was received by the institution. Profile has something similar. Date it was submitted, the date it was processed, the date the institution receives it.
Jonathan Hughes: Oh, okay.
Jim Slattery: We get all of that. We tend to honor submission date in the end, but I can’t say that for every institution.
Jonathan Hughes: Thinking about a family that is getting ready to file their CSS Profile form, and they’re trying to gather all their resources, what are the things that they should gather up?
Jim Slattery: Tax returns. There g- there were questions about their tax return. Some of it’s intended to make it easy, right? The profile will say, “This is the question.
You could look at this line on your return.” So tax returns are an [00:27:00] obvious one. The underlying documents, as I talked about, W-2s, 1099s and so on. Banking statements, so that includes not only what you have in the bank, what you have for assets, but it would include information about your home. So you’re gonna be asked about your home value, and then you’re gonna be asked the debt on the home, and that’s a good thing, right?
In other words, the, the equity is what matters to the institution, not just the value. So if you owe a lot on an expensive home, it’s the equity, the difference that’s looked at. The profile site has some very good instructions that talks about preparing for the form and preparing documentation before you go in and enter.
The other piece we should mention for both Profile and FAFSA is you can go into these forms and leave them. So even if you didn’t have full preparation or have access to every last document needed, you could save your application, find the information, go back in. But in general, it’s gonna be those common sense financial statements, banking statements, information [00:28:00] about your home, tax returns, and underlying tax information.
Jonathan Hughes: I wanna ask you about the question on the profile that probably drives the most questions to us here and I’m sure you know where I’m going with this. I’m gonna read it word for word so that surprise me. Oh, yeah. “What amount will the parent contribute toward the student’s educational cost?” This really flummoxes parents. They don’t know how to answer this question. What would you say?
Jim Slattery: I would say, and it’s what I’ve said for many years to families, to relatives, to the in-laws, good friends Be as honest as you can, which sounds like a very simplistic answer. So let me give you some truth about it.
It is– it reads like a loaded question, doesn’t it? It really does. I could tell this f- tell families for certain. Number one, it’s not part of any formula. It’s not part of the base formula for profile, for institutional [00:29:00] methodology. It’s simply not a data point in any formula. I don’t know an institution that incorporates it in any formula or incorporates it in a regular way.
Now, that said, it’s on the form because some institutions like it as an informational piece, right? For some places, it’s a litmus test, right? A common sense test. You’ve provided this information. Does that align with what you think you can offer, right? But even that information, as much as that’s helpful on the surface, that can make a f- a family crazy, and I’ve been that applicant.
It can make you crazy. If I go too high, are they gonna presume that’s– are they just gonna take it? If I say I can contribute $30,000, but their analysis said 20, are they gonna assume 30? Some institutions may. Conversely, if I say zero, are they gonna think I’m not engaged or don’t care or don’t wanna participate?
Some institutions may say that. Just like some of the other pieces where we said there might be different deadlines or different approaches to deadlines, there’s no [00:30:00] magic answer because institutions may look at it in different ways. I don’t know an institution that looks at it nefariously. It’s used as informational. Some ignore it. Many ignore it. I shouldn’t say some. Many ignore it. Many look at it later in the process if there’s an appeal or a reconsideration from the family, then it becomes a, a common sense kind of data point. But the- And
Jonathan Hughes: when you say common sense, what do you mean by that?
Jim Slattery: Common sense to the institution. Okay. It may not be common sense to the families. Again, it becomes a, a kind of either a lens or a due diligence point to see if the family’s expectation or th- or view of their ability to pay is in line with the analysis. I see. But again, just– but as I said, because it’s not part of a formula, that view may have zero impact on the eligibility for the family.
And so that’s why I do say Think about it, be honest about it. Don’t let it make you, you insane, ’cause it could make you insane. Don’t dwell on [00:31:00] it, and know because institutions can use it differently, there’s no magic way… I- if there was a way to game the question- … or a trick, we’d reveal to your audience the trick today.
But there is no trick to it. And then the last thing I’ll say, and this applies to the entire process, if in the end, there are mysterious elements to this process. Institutions by nature, if they’re private and it’s their own dollars, you might not have every insight, just like you don’t to an admissions process.
Jonathan Hughes: Sure.
Jim Slattery: Families say, “I’m not really sure what they’re choosing or what they’re emphasizing.” That’s true. In the end, most institutions will reveal it. So we’ve had families who’ve said, “I get this analysis from you. This is the award. It seems very different than what I expected. Could it have had to- something to do with that number I put in or that magic question?” We’ll be honest about that.
Jonathan Hughes: Yeah.
Jim Slattery: And I– Most institutions, I think, will be honest about that. So I say give it your best honest answer, move on, don’t dwell on it. It is [00:32:00] confusing. It is anxiety driven, but a lot of the process is well,
Jonathan Hughes: I guess that kind of brings me to my last question, and it’s something that we’ve been alluding to here and there, and that is, you just mentioned, the, the financial aid office will be forthcoming with the parents if they have questions, and you’ve also mentioned that this process is a personal one.
It asks personal questions and that can lead parents to feel hesitant to engage or maybe a little guarded. What would you say to parents who may feel that way?
Jim Slattery: First of all, we understand why families feel guarded, and I think even societally, the o- the one place where you very often have to reveal Financial information has to do with the IRS, where there’s, there tends to be a kind of less is better philosophy, right?
The less I tell them the better off I am. That’s a kind of instinct. With financial aid and with colleges, I say try to repress those [00:33:00] instincts. We have a very detailed process. Profile especially is a very detailed process, but it’s not perfect. There are family circumstances that don’t get covered or revealed through that process.
The only way the college could know that is if you connect with them directly and reveal that. I assure you, most colleges aren’t looking for more information. They’re not looking for reasons to not give you money. They’re looking for reasons to help families, to give them money. I assure you, the individuals working in these offices, that’s their philosophy.
I don’t know of a financial aid administrator who’s getting risk- rich being a financial aid administrator. They’re doing it because they enjoy working with families and enjoy working for their institutions and working for the broader enterprise of higher ed, right? And colleges, as, as complex as they can be, and as much as we’re dealing with high numbers, scary numbers, they want to engage with families and help out families, and ultimately, remember, they want to enroll some- [00:34:00] your son or daughter, right? There’s a self-interest element on their part that you should be thinking about when you engage with them, too.
Jonathan Hughes: Jim, thank you so much for being here. It was a pleasure.
Jim Slattery: My pleasure.
Jonathan Hughes: I know this answers a lot of questions that folks have.
And remember, just because the CSS Profile is more complicated than the FAFSA, it doesn’t mean it’s too complicated to file, and it is well worth it to do so. Now until next time, my name is Jonathan Hughes, and this has been the MEFA podcast.


