Researching Colleges When You Can't Visit Campus
As a component of MEFA's work in the Commonwealth to help students and families access and afford higher education, I serve as a committee member for Reach Higher Massachusetts, an association of professionals that works together to motivate and support students as they pursue their goals for post-secondary education. Dr. Tim Poynton, a college professor and one of my partners on the Reach Higher committee, recently shared some guidance that he and his colleague Dr. Richard Lapan put together on the college search process during this time of quarantine. I appreciated their helpful tips for students who are just starting to learn about their different college options, and the different online resources they highlighted. If you're a Grade 11 student or the family of one, I invite you to review the guidance below from these two experienced educators.
Within this time of our current pandemic, most college campuses have temporarily closed their doors. That means high school juniors, who would normally spend time during spring break and summer vacation touring campuses, will need to use other means to learn more about the colleges to which they might apply. If you're in this boat, consider this an opportunity. When you dig deeper into the facts about colleges you're considering, you will be in a much better position to make an informed decision.
Although visiting college campuses is a time-honored strategy for comparing and choosing a college, those visits can unleash a flood of emotions that can cloud students' judgment and obscure facts. On a college visit, students see beautiful, well-landscaped campuses with energetic and likable tour guides, and students outside enjoying themselves. You may have positive feelings about how much you would like to attend a college as a result of that experience. Don't underestimate how these emotions can bias you when you make the college decision. Balancing those emotions with facts will lead to more informed decision-making.
Answer the questions below about each of the colleges you are seriously considering. Most of this information (and more) is available from the College Navigator, a searchable database of information for colleges in the United States. You'll learn about your college costs in the financial aid offers you receive upon acceptance, but for now you can estimate costs using a Net Price Calculator or on the College Navigator website.
Question 1: How supported and satisfied are freshmen?
Look at the retention rate for full-time students in the Retention and Graduation Rates section of College Navigator. The Retention Rate describes the percent of full-time students who returned to the college as sophomores. Think of the Retention Rate as the "freshmen satisfaction score," because it describes the percent of students who were satisfied with and supported by the college enough to return as sophomores.
Question 2: How many students make it to graduation?
This information is also in the Retention and Graduation Rates section of the College Navigator. Pay particular attention to the Graduation Rates for Students Pursuing Bachelor's Degrees section, where it indicates what percentage of freshmen make it through to graduation at that college in four or six years. Also make note of the Transfer-Out Rate, which tells you the percent of students who transferred to another college before graduation.
Question 3: How likely am I to have close interactions with professors?
You can find the student-to-faculty ratio up near the top of the page in the College Navigator. Colleges with lower student-to-faculty ratios tend to have more small classes, while colleges with higher ratios tend to have more large lecture hall type classes.
Question 4: How many other students are in the major(s) I am interested in?
In the Programs/Majors section of the College Navigator, you can find how many people received bachelor's degrees across all of the programs offered. Review this list for two reasons. First, ensure the college offers programs you are interested in. Second, take a look at how many students graduate with degrees in the areas you are interested in. The number of students graduating with the degrees of interest to you can lead to other questions. For example, if only three people graduate with a degree in a program you are interested in, you may want to find out why.
Question 5: How diverse is the student body?
In the Enrollment section of the College Navigator, review the Undergraduate Race/Ethnicity information to see how ethnically diverse the student body is. While most of the categories here make intuitive sense, note that the "nonresident alien" category refers to international students.
Question 6: How much will it cost to attend this college?
The best source of information to answer this question will come from the college itself, communicated in a financial aid offer to you. Before you receive that, use the Net Price Calculator for the college or information provided in the Net Price section of the College Navigator to estimate first year costs. Other questions to consider when thinking about costs are: "How do I maintain scholarship eligibility?" and "How much are costs likely to rise over the next few years?" These are questions a financial aid or admissions counselor from the college can likely answer easily. Also, try to think about the difference between price and value as you reflect on your findings. For example, if College A ($12,000/year) has smaller classes and more programs of study you are interested in than College B ($10,000/year), College A may be the better value for you even though it has a higher price. When you have a good idea of how much each college will cost, take it a step further on your own and figure out what your monthly loan payment will be if you end up needing to borrow.
Question 7: What is the average salary of graduates?
The College Scorecard shows the starting salary range for graduates. Navigate to the Fields of Study section and review the Highest Earnings for the 10 top earning majors at the college. You may be able to find a specific major of interest by exploring this website further.
Debunk College Myths
Myth 1: "The college I choose determines the next four years of my life."
Fact: Students can and do transfer from one college to another all the time. In fact, about one in three students transfer at least once before finishing a degree. Of course, it's easier if you do not transfer colleges. Transferring may lead to lost credits and delay your graduation. But to think you can't change your mind later is not helpful or accurate.
Myth 2: "I have to decide on a major before I get to college."
Fact: Knowing what you want to study can be helpful, but it's okay if you aren't sure. Most colleges give you time to explore before formally declaring a major. About one in three students change their major at least once. In most majors, you have time to explore and figure out what you want to study and still graduate within four years, although some STEM majors are an exception.
Myth 3: "There is only one college that is right for me."
Fact: There are many good colleges; making a college choice is a good problem to have. You are likely making a choice among many good options. You are more responsible for your success than the college you attend. You create your own success; the college does not create it for you.
Myth 4: "A college education is not worth the money."
Fact: People with a bachelor's degree earn $461 more each week than people with a high school diploma. That's nearly $24,000 a year and nearly $1 million dollars across a 40-year career. College is expensive, and we all wish it were cheaper, but it is a sound investment for most people.
Assembling all of this information in one place about the colleges you are considering should make it easy for you to think critically and carefully about each college. The goal of this activity is not to necessarily have you determine a numerical rank and then use that number to determine which college you should attend. However, the facts you assembled about each college provide a solid foundation upon which to make sound, reasoned judgments and maybe even gather more information. For example, you may find that the retention or graduation rate at a school that you really like is a bit lower than all the other colleges on your list. Reach out to an admission counselor to ask about it, and see if they have made any changes recently.
Lastly, have conversations with people you trust and know well to discuss your choices – your school counselor, parents, mentor or a trusted family friend. Take the time to present the facts you have learned, and, ultimately, justify why the college you are choosing to attend is the best one for you. As you do this, be open to gathering and learning new information with the feedback you receive. Taking the time to gather and process this information will result in an informed decision you can feel good about – in spite of not being able to visit the campus.
Dr. Tim Poynton is a Professor and Counselor Educator committed to improving the transition from high school into young adulthood through his research and teaching. A former school counselor, Dr. Poynton is currently an associate professor in the department of Counseling & School Psychology at the University of Massachusetts Boston. Dr. Poynton has published several research articles and book chapters related to school counseling, career development, and college readiness, and was recognized in 2011 as the Counselor Educator of the Year by the American School Counselor Association.
A tenured professor, counselor educator, and psychologist at the University of Massachusetts Amherst, Richard Lapan is one of the most highly cited scholars in the efforts to transform the profession of school counseling from an ancillary support service to a comprehensive program central to the academic, career, and social emotional development of every young person. His numerous research articles and books have made Dr. Lapan a national and international leader, recognized by the American School Counselor Association when they awarded him the prestigious Counselor Educator of the Year award in 2006. Dr. Lapan has had extensive work experiences providing counseling services (individual, group, crisis, career, family, and residential services) to children, adolescents, and adults.